Although each of the three cognitive structures play an
important role and tie into each other, I believe values hold the most importance.
All opinions and attitudes are essentially derived from an individual’s
values. These values are the strongest,
most personal, and deeply held opinions to audience members’ identities. Values are a part of everyone, they are
typically beliefs that are deeply ingrained in an individual. Hence, understanding the values of the
audience can have a significant impact on the structure of the speech.
Sunday, February 19, 2012
Values
When communicating, whether it be a speech or a regular
conversation, people bring personally imbedded beliefs, attitudes, values and
life experiences with them. For a person
communicating to an audience this is important to understand. Failing to do so can result in minimal
understanding of what is attempting to be communicated. According to psychologist Milton Rokeach, the
human mind uses three kinds of cognitive structures. Beliefs, attitudes, and values are important
structures each audience member holds.
President Barack Obama
President Barack Obama is easily today’s best speaker. He possesses all three characteristic that
affect the audience. He has credibility
(aside from the regular political issues), he maintains attractiveness, and has
the power. I believe these three characteristics
are the reason why he got elected to become President. President Obama maintains great credibility
because of the relatively drama-free past which reflected well during the
election. He was a younger, healthy, and
attractive contender that made us, the audience, feel a sense of comfort and
likability. The last important aspect
President Obama carried was power. He
did a great job influencing the voters by creating an atmosphere that this
campaign directly affected the voter’s lives.
The promises that he made were more believable and gained the trust and
vote of many young voters. Every time I watch
his speech, my eyes were glued to the television. The way he speaks, the use of his vocabulary
and the confidence he has when addressing the nation makes me believe most of
what he is saying. I believe President
Obama has ethos build all areas characteristics that affect the audience, and I
believe this was the main reason why he won the election in 2008. He knew how to communicate and connect with
his target audience.
Saturday, February 18, 2012
Influencial Speaker
Yes, I have been influenced by a speaker. The best speak that I can recollect is the inaugural
speech by John F. Kennedy. Even though I
was born when this speech took place, throughout my life I heard quotes that
came from this speech that I embraced. Most significantly, the quote, “ask not what
your country can do for your, ask what you can do for your country” is what I believe
as an American has influence actions in my life.
John F Kennedy made this communication memorable because the
speech was well written and well said. The
speech held lots of energy, confidence, and true devotion to the speech,
allowing for the audience to become a motivated and proud American. The way he incorporated all the essential
topics current at that time was another mastery of art to put the power into
the peoples hand to make a change. He
did a great job bringing the audience as part an essential piece to speech.
The worst speaker I can remember off the top of my head was
the 2004 Iowa Democratic caucuses. Howard Dean wasn’t
a horrible public speaker per se, but I did not remember anything about his
message. That is without saying the obvious
“vote for me”. I don’t remember anything
content of the speech other than the infamous “Dean Scream”. I also don’t remember what the selling point or
advantage of having him as the president was.
His “show” distracted me from the important information what he had to
offer went completely out of the window.
Sunday, February 12, 2012
Psychological Model
I found the psychological model to be useful because, as the
book mentions, it is the basis of most models and definition of communication. This model is a psychological process whereby
two (or more) individuals exchange meanings though the transmission and
reception of communication stimuli (pg 24).
What I appreciate about the model is the simplicity to visually see the
process of this model. The “sender” is
the individual who conveys or “encodes” the information. The information is known as the “message” and
it travels along “channels” until it reaches its “destination” where the “receiver”
would be. The “receiver” then “decodes”
the “message” and replies a “feedback”. Like
the other models, there are variables that we have to consider. The “mental set” are set beliefs, values, attitudes,
and all other aspects that make an individual an individual. The obstacle the “message” might encounter
which it is traveling along the “channel” are “noises”. “Noise” is any distraction that interferes
with the intended message. The psychological
model shows us a simplistic view of communication and its variable.
Pragmatic Perspective
The pragmatic model is perspective that makes sense as a patterned game. It shows communication as a system of interlocking, interdependent behavior that become patterned over time (pg31). By patterned interaction, we as individuals that communicate to one another are considered to be “partners”. As we communicate, we make moves or “acts” that over a course of a conversation become “interactions”. These interactions, whether it may be a debate or a simple conversation have intended purposes. The intent of the conversation can vary from making a point in an argument, conveying information, or to persuade someone to name a few examples. These goals are considered to be “payoffs” of the individuals participating in the interaction. The purpose of the conversation requires, at the simplest pattern, have a two-act sequence that become “interdependent”. This is because the payoffs require and depend on the actions of the partner participating in this game. The pragmatic perspective become patterned interactions as people or the “players” get to know each other and learn how to work and communicate.
The pragmatic perspective uses a game as an analogy because of the interdependence of the players. Everyone that communicates is a “player”, and each “player” is affected by what the other “player” does. These “players” are required to play this “game” whether the players realizes it or not. An interesting point the book makes is that these interactions can vary and whether the communicator responds or not, it is a form of communication. The pragmatic perspective looks at this as “we cannot not communicate”. Ultimately the purpose of the “game” is to gain the most “payoff”.
How is it different than a game? This differs from a game because this model does not take cultural or personality viewpoints. A game has fixed options or variables that can be conducted. This dismisses multiple factors such as desire, intentions, needs, and cultural context surrounding interaction to find out why people act as they do.
The pragmatic perspective uses a game as an analogy because of the interdependence of the players. Everyone that communicates is a “player”, and each “player” is affected by what the other “player” does. These “players” are required to play this “game” whether the players realizes it or not. An interesting point the book makes is that these interactions can vary and whether the communicator responds or not, it is a form of communication. The pragmatic perspective looks at this as “we cannot not communicate”. Ultimately the purpose of the “game” is to gain the most “payoff”.
How is it different than a game? This differs from a game because this model does not take cultural or personality viewpoints. A game has fixed options or variables that can be conducted. This dismisses multiple factors such as desire, intentions, needs, and cultural context surrounding interaction to find out why people act as they do.
Saturday, February 11, 2012
Social Constructionist Perspective
Social constructionist perspective “build worlds” through a
process whereby people in groups, using the tools provided by their culture,
create collective representation of reality (pg 28). We take symbolic codes, cognitive customs,
cultural tradition, and sets of roles and rules to build our perspective of the
world. As the book mentions, social
constructionist perspective never experiences the world directly. Perspectives of the world are greatly
determined by social and cultural influences.
We, in our culture see diversity as the norm. Many cultures and countries are not used to
such diversity of race, religion or creed.
For those cultures, seeing someone of different color or religion might
be fearful or intrigued in that individual, as in our culture they are just
another person. In a communication
aspect of differences in cultures, many “old school” thoughts derived from our grandparent’s
generation are much more different than our current outlook on social norms. Individuals a century ago had very different
communicative methods in comparison to today.
European Americans spoke differently to African Americans, men spoke to
women different, and socio-economic classes communicated differently among
other classes. All these are different
today because our language, how we were taught differently to process
information, our beliefs, attitudes, values, and our set rules that guide our
actions have completely changed.
These concepts contribute to our happiness and success as a
society to grow and learn how to live together.
This has benefited us as Americans in such diversity. I believe we are
much more open to different ideas in comparison to much of the world and can
communicate more effectively because of this.
Sunday, February 5, 2012
The Final Canon
The five canons of rhetoric was the early model of
communication was an early concept that Cicero had establish as five major
topic areas of communication. Invention,
style, arraignment, memory, and delivery all tied into what was considered to
be the basis of effective communication.
The concept I wanted to elaborate on is the final canon, delivery. Although the Greeks and Romans considered
delivery as less important in comparison to the other canons, they understood
the significance of non-verbal communication.
I consider this to be an important element to the function of
communication. The speaker could know everything
about a topic that is being presented, but if the deliverance is not well
played, it does not allow the opportunity to capture the audience’s
attention. Cicero displayed the need for
nonverbal communication as a tool to make an audience feel a part of the
emotions. Such deliverance as a pleasing
voice and graceful gesture are necessary for the success of the effect of the speech.
Orators
This is a difficult question to answers objectively because
of the variability of the definition of “morally good”. I do agree with the Greeks in a sense that
great orators believed their intent was for the greater good and spoke the
truth that was believed. Where I disagree
is the historical proof that there have been, by my definition, leaders of
extremely horrible morality, which were amazing orators. The prime example I have is Adolf
Hitler. I believe his intent and method
of achieving his goals to “purify” the world are not practices of a person of
goodness and truth. However, in his mind
and in the mind of his followers Hitler may have been looked at as the goodness
and truth for the people making him an individual of morally good. The connection between goodness, truth, and
public speaking comes from the passion the speaker embraces. If that individual does genuinely believes in
a particular matter that allows the speaker to become a great orator.
Saturday, February 4, 2012
A Speaker I Admire
One of the people I admire most as a speaker is my good
friend Ali. He has been a suit salesman
most of his life, and has the ability to persuade people in any direction he
wants. It is one of the most amazing
things to watch. Not only can he use his
skills to sell suits, he is able to use it in his day to day life. I believe his power to persuade comes mostly
from ethos, but logos as well. He has
the ability to make anything logical from any situation. My ability to persuade comes primarily from
pathos and logos. I tend to tie in logic
and correlation with a lot of my arguments.
In addition, emotions can influence a decision to be favorable if the
argument does not have a solid logical explanation. I
believe Aristotle’s classification scheme works at all levels, because they are
such broad categories. When looking
deeper into how they work, I believe other categories will be easier to
classify.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)